
Dummies! Some parents absolutely love them, while others are hesitant to introduce one because they're worried about creating a sleep association they'll eventually have to deal with.
And it's a fair concern, particularly when you've heard stories about babies waking every 45 minutes overnight because their dummy has fallen out!
But here's the thing. Dummies aren't automatically a problem, and they can actually be a really useful settling tool during the newborn stage.
Sucking is a natural reflex for newborns, and many babies find it comforting, particularly when they're unsettled or need additional support to fall asleep.
There are also safe sleep benefits worth understanding, including the association between offering a dummy at sleep times and a reduced risk of SIDS.
However, as your baby grows, the way they use their dummy can change, and for some families it can eventually contribute to frequent night waking.
So should you introduce a dummy? And if you do, how do you know when it's helping sleep versus when it might be contributing to the problem?
Let's talk about it.
Why pacifiers can help newborn sleep
Newborns are born with a natural sucking reflex, and sucking can be incredibly comforting for many babies.
It's why you might notice your newborn wanting to suck even when they've recently finished a feed, or why they seem to settle almost immediately when offered a dummy.
During those early weeks and months, a dummy can be a really useful tool for helping your baby settle, particularly when they're unsettled, struggling to fall asleep or simply looking for some additional comfort.
For some newborns, offering a dummy can help them settle between feeds, provide comfort during those particularly unsettled evening periods and make the transition into sleep a little easier.
And importantly, using a dummy during the newborn stage doesn't automatically mean you're creating a sleep problem for later!
Newborns often need plenty of support to fall asleep, whether that's feeding, rocking, holding or using a dummy.
However, it's important to remember that a dummy shouldn't be used to delay or replace a feed when your baby is showing signs of hunger.
There are also safe sleep considerations. Offering a dummy when placing your baby down for sleep is associated with a reduced risk of SIDS. If you're breastfeeding, it's generally recommended to wait until feeding is well established before introducing one, and you don't need to put the dummy back in if it falls out once your baby is asleep.
If you're unsure what's normal when it comes to newborn settling and sleep, our What to Expect With Newborn Sleep blog explains what you can realistically expect during those early months.
Newborn sleep cycles are generally around 45–60 minutes, and during these cycles, your baby will move through different stages of sleep.
You might notice them stirring, wriggling, making little noises or briefly opening their eyes before either continuing to sleep or waking completely.
For some newborns, offering a dummy can help them settle back to sleep when they wake, particularly if sucking is something they find comforting.
But here's where I want to make an important distinction.
Just because your newborn wakes after 45 minutes doesn't automatically mean they've woken because their dummy has fallen out!
Newborns wake for lots of reasons, including hunger, discomfort, sleep pressure and their individual sleep needs.
And while a dummy can be helpful for settling, it doesn't mean your baby needs it replaced every time they stir or move between sleep stages.
In fact, sometimes your baby might simply be experiencing active sleep and not need any intervention at all.
And PLEASE don't worry that offering your newborn a dummy now means you're setting yourself up for months of broken sleep later.
During those early weeks, your baby is adjusting to life outside the womb, feeding frequently and still developing more organised sleep patterns. If a dummy helps them settle, there's absolutely nothing wrong with using it!
You don't need to withhold a useful settling tool because you're worried about a sleep association that may or may not become an issue months down the track.
As your baby grows, you might find they become more reliant on having their dummy replaced to fall asleep again. For some families, this can contribute to frequent night waking, particularly when parents are replacing it multiple times throughout the night.
But that doesn't happen to every baby, and it's something you can reassess if it becomes a problem.
For now, if your newborn is feeding well, growing appropriately and the dummy is helping everyone get a little more sleep, you don't need to rush to remove it.
If you'd like to understand more about what's happening during those shorter periods of sleep, have a read of our Newborn Sleep Cycles blog.
Not necessarily! And this is where I think parents need to understand the difference between using a dummy as a helpful settling tool and having a dummy that's contributing to frequent night waking.
During the newborn stage, it's completely normal for your baby to need help with settling, whether that's feeding, rocking, holding or having their dummy replaced.
And if your newborn is waking frequently overnight, I wouldn't automatically blame the dummy.
Newborns have immature sleep patterns, need regular feeds and often require additional support to fall asleep. Removing the dummy isn't necessarily going to change any of those things.
However, as your baby gets older, you might notice that the dummy starts becoming more disruptive than helpful.
For example, your baby might initially fall asleep beautifully with their dummy, but then wake every 30–45 minutes and need you to replace it before they can fall asleep again.
And suddenly, you're spending your entire night playing dummy patrol!
This is when I would start looking at whether the dummy is contributing to those frequent wakings, rather than automatically assuming it's a sleep regression or something your baby will grow out of.
But here's the important part: there isn't a magical age when dummies suddenly become a problem.
Some babies happily use a dummy without it affecting their sleep, while others become increasingly reliant on having it replaced.
And some babies eventually become capable of finding and replacing their own dummy, which can make a big difference.
So if your newborn is using a dummy and it's working well for your family, there's no reason to remove it simply because you're worried about what might happen later.
You can always reassess as your baby grows and their sleep needs change.
Did you know that offering your baby a dummy when putting them down for sleep is associated with a reduced risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS)?
It's one of the reasons dummies are often discussed as part of safe sleep recommendations.
However, there are a few important things parents should know about using them safely.
You can offer your baby a dummy when settling them for naps and overnight sleep, but there's no need to force it if they're not interested.
And if their dummy falls out once they're asleep? You don't need to keep putting it back in!
It's also important to make sure the dummy is the appropriate size for your baby's age, is in good condition and is used without cords, clips, chains or soft toy attachments during sleep.
If you're breastfeeding, it's generally recommended to wait until breastfeeding is well established before introducing a dummy, so it doesn't interfere with establishing feeding.
And remember, a dummy should never replace a feed when your newborn is showing signs of hunger.
While offering a dummy at sleep times is associated with a reduced risk of SIDS, it doesn't replace other important safe sleep practices, including placing your baby on their back, using a firm, flat mattress and keeping their sleep space free from loose bedding, pillows and soft toys.
You can read more about creating a safe sleep environment in our Safe Sleep guide.
Pacifiers and a newborn night routine
During those early newborn weeks, a dummy can be a really helpful part of your baby's bedtime routine, particularly if they're unsettled in the evenings or need some additional comfort before falling asleep.
You might offer a dummy after a feed, while having a cuddle or when placing your baby down in their cot for sleep.
And remember, your newborn doesn't need a complicated bedtime routine!
Something as simple as a feed, nappy change, sleeping bag, dimmed lights and some quiet time together can help create a familiar pattern before sleep.
If your baby finds sucking comforting, offering their dummy can naturally become part of that routine.
But there's no need to insist on using one if your baby isn't interested, and you certainly don't need to keep replacing it once they've fallen asleep.
At this age, the goal isn't to get your newborn falling asleep independently at every sleep or following a strict schedule.
It's about creating a predictable environment, meeting their feeding and comfort needs, and giving them opportunities to sleep when they're ready.
And if you're wondering what a realistic bedtime routine actually looks like during those first few months, our Creating a Newborn Night Routine blog walks you through it.
Not necessarily! Plenty of babies use a dummy without it ever becoming a significant sleep issue.
But for some families, there comes a point when the dummy starts causing more disruption than it's actually helping.
You might find that your baby initially falls asleep beautifully with their dummy, but then starts waking every 30–45 minutes overnight and needs you to replace it EVERY single time.
And suddenly, something that was once helping everyone get more sleep is now keeping you up all night!
This doesn't happen to every baby, though.
Some babies naturally lose interest in their dummy, while others eventually become capable of finding and replacing it themselves.
And for some families, removing the dummy becomes the most practical option when frequent waking is clearly linked to needing it replaced.
But here's the thing: you don't need to remove your newborn's dummy now because you're worried it might become a problem later.
If it's helping your baby settle and everyone is sleeping reasonably well, there's no reason to rush into changing something that's working.
If the dummy does start contributing to frequent waking as your baby gets older, you can reassess whether it's time to make a change.
And while some families prefer a gradual approach, others find that removing the dummy altogether works better, depending on their baby's age and circumstances.
If you're wondering when it might be time to say goodbye to the dummy, our Weaning the Dummy blog explains what to consider and how to approach the transition.
So how do you know when your baby's dummy has gone from being a helpful settling tool to something that's actually contributing to broken sleep?
For some families, this becomes more noticeable around four months and beyond, when sleep patterns are changing and babies may begin waking more frequently overnight.
You might notice your baby falling asleep easily with their dummy at bedtime, only to wake every 30–45 minutes needing you to put it back in.
And we're not talking about replacing it once or twice overnight. We're talking about spending your entire night going back and forth to the cot!
Another thing to consider is whether your baby can fall asleep without their dummy, or whether they become increasingly distressed every time it falls out.
But here's where I would be careful about automatically blaming the dummy.
If your baby is waking frequently, we still need to consider their individual sleep needs, awake time, nap distribution, feeding requirements and whether they have enough sleep pressure to remain asleep.
Removing the dummy won't automatically fix frequent night waking if the dummy isn't actually what's causing it.
On the other hand, if your baby's routine is appropriate, their feeding needs are being met and they're consistently waking because they need the dummy replaced, then it might be worth considering whether continuing to use it is working for your family.
And remember, there's no rule that says you HAVE to remove the dummy at four months, six months or any other specific age simply because your baby is waking overnight.
It's about understanding what's contributing to the waking and making a decision based on your baby's individual circumstances.
Some babies absolutely love their dummy, while others will spit it out the second you offer it. And both are completely normal!
If your newborn finds comfort in sucking and a dummy helps them settle, there's no reason to feel guilty about using one.
Equally, if your baby has absolutely no interest in a dummy, you don't need to keep trying to introduce one.
And PLEASE don't feel pressured to remove a dummy that's working well simply because someone has told you it'll create bad habits later.
The reality is that your baby's sleep needs will change as they grow, and something that works beautifully during the newborn stage might need reassessing a few months down the track.
That doesn't mean introducing the dummy was a mistake!
What matters is whether it's helping your baby and your family right now, while recognising when it might be time to make an adjustment.
You don't need to solve a sleep problem that doesn't exist yet.
If you are not sure whether your baby's routine is right for this stage, or sleep is starting to feel really hard, our team is here to help.
Based in Melbourne, Australia and supporting families Australia-wide, our team offers:
30-minute sleep consultation - a focused session where we look at your baby's routine, naps, feeds, awake windows, and overnight waking, then give you clear, practical next steps tailored to your family.
Two Week Sleep Support - a fully guided two-week program that includes a personalised sleep plan, a 60-minute consultation, and 10 days of weekday support while you make changes. Ideal if sleep feels really unsustainable and you want more hands-on help.
In-home sleep support - hands-on, face-to-face support for families in Melbourne, Sydney, Byron Bay Shire, Gold Coast and surrounding areas who want someone there with them through the process.
The Sleepy Little Bubs is based in Melbourne and offers virtual sleep consultations across Australia and worldwide.
Whether you need quick clarity or more structured support, we can help you find the right next step.


"Eva is fantastic and helped my family get better sleep."
"I loved the practical advice and lack of judgement - being a mum of a baby who doesn’t sleep is hard and Eva really just gets it and supports you."
- Ashleigh T.


"Eva helped our little one sleep independently and we will forever be grateful for it!"
"After tweaking his environment and wake windows, with sleep training, we already saw improvements within 3 days. Thank you 🙏🏼"
- Farah F.


"Eva showed such kindness and professionalism in our support call."
"I’m so grateful that she made the effort to squeeze me in on short notice, to help a mama in dire need. She’s a gem!
- Johanna S.
