
If your newborn is relatively happy and content throughout the day, but come 4.00pm or 5.00pm they suddenly become unsettled, fussy and seemingly impossible to please, welcome to what many parents call the witching hour!
You might find yourself constantly feeding, rocking, walking around the house or trying absolutely EVERYTHING to settle your baby, only for the same thing to happen again the following evening.
And while it's incredibly exhausting, particularly when you've already spent the entire day caring for a newborn, this late-afternoon and evening fussiness is really common during those early weeks and months.
But why does it happen, and is there anything you can actually do to help?
The witching hour is a term used to describe that lovely (not!) period in the late afternoon or evening when your otherwise happy newborn suddenly becomes incredibly unsettled.
You might notice your baby crying more than usual, wanting to feed constantly, refusing to be put down or fighting sleep despite showing signs of tiredness.
And despite the name, it doesn't necessarily last just one hour! For some babies, the fussiness might last 30 minutes, while for others it can stretch across several hours.
It often starts during the first few weeks of life, tends to peak around six to eight weeks and gradually improves as your baby gets older.
There isn't one single reason why the witching hour happens. Your baby's nervous system is still developing, and factors such as accumulated stimulation, feeding patterns and tiredness may all contribute to those unsettled evenings.
And while it's a common part of early infancy, not every baby will experience it, and the intensity can vary enormously from one newborn to another.
Ahhh, if you've ever spent your entire evening pacing the hallway, bouncing your newborn, offering another feed and wondering WHY nothing seems to be working, you might be experiencing the witching hour!
While it can look a little different for every baby, some common signs include:
Crying and fussiness that seems to ramp up around the same time every afternoon or evening.
Wanting to feed constantly, sometimes in short bursts, without seeming completely satisfied.
Showing signs of tiredness but struggling to fall asleep or stay asleep.
Being perfectly content in your arms but becoming upset the moment you try to put them down.
Settling for 10 or 15 minutes, only to wake up crying again.
Needing far more holding, rocking, feeding or reassurance than they did earlier in the day.
And sometimes, despite trying absolutely EVERYTHING, your baby just seems impossible to settle.
The important thing to remember is that evening fussiness is common during the newborn stage, and it doesn't automatically mean there's something wrong.
However, not all crying should be dismissed as the witching hour. If your baby is unusually distressed, their crying sounds different from normal, they're feeding poorly, have a fever or seem unwell, it's important to seek medical advice rather than assuming it's just a developmental phase.
There isn't one single reason why newborns experience the witching hour. In fact, it's usually a combination of things happening throughout the day that can make those late afternoons and evenings particularly challenging.
Let's look at a few of the possible reasons.
Your Baby's Developing Nervous System
Your newborn is taking in SO much information throughout the day. Lights, sounds, movement, being passed around for cuddles, tummy time and even everyday household noise.
Their nervous system is still developing, and processing all that stimulation can be a lot for such a little person!
By the late afternoon or evening, some babies may find it harder to settle, particularly after a busy day with lots of activity.
Newborn Sleep Cycles
Newborn sleep is quite different from adult sleep, and their sleep patterns are still developing during those early months.
Newborn sleep cycles are generally around 45–60 minutes, and babies can move between different stages of sleep quite frequently.
This means you might find your baby settles for a short nap, only to wake again 30 or 40 minutes later, particularly during those unsettled evening hours.
You can read more about how this works in our Newborn Sleep Cycles blog.
However, short sleep cycles alone don't explain the witching hour, and frequent waking during the newborn stage is completely normal.
Sleep Pressure and Awake Time
This is something I always encourage parents to consider!
By the time late afternoon rolls around, your newborn may have had several short naps, longer periods awake or simply not enough sleep throughout the day.
And while we absolutely need enough sleep pressure for a baby to fall asleep, pushing them beyond their threshold can make settling much harder.
On the other hand, if your baby has had plenty of sleep throughout the day and hasn't built enough sleep pressure, they might not actually be ready for another nap just yet.
This is why I don't recommend assuming every unsettled newborn is overtired.
Looking at how much sleep they've had, how long they've been awake and their individual sleep needs can help you understand what might be happening.
Cluster Feeding
Ahhh, cluster feeding! If you've ever felt like you've spent the entire evening feeding your newborn, only for them to want another feed 20 minutes later, you'll know exactly what I'm talking about.
Many newborns naturally feed more frequently during the late afternoon and evening, particularly during those early weeks.
This can be completely normal and doesn't automatically mean your milk supply is low or that something is wrong.
However, if your baby seems constantly hungry, isn't gaining weight as expected or you're concerned about feeding, it's worth speaking with your maternal and child health nurse, midwife or an IBCLC.
Digestive Discomfort
Your newborn's digestive system is still developing, and some babies experience wind, discomfort or difficulties with feeding that can contribute to fussiness.
You might notice your baby pulling their legs up, squirming, becoming unsettled after feeds or seeming uncomfortable when lying down.
Reflux or other feeding-related difficulties may also contribute to unsettled behaviour in some babies, although not every baby who cries in the evening has reflux!
If your baby appears to be in pain, is frequently vomiting, feeding poorly or seems consistently distressed, it's important to seek medical advice rather than assuming it's simply the witching hour.
The good news? The witching hour doesn't last forever, even though those evenings can certainly feel like they do!
For many newborns, evening fussiness starts during the first few weeks of life, tends to peak around six to eight weeks and gradually improves by around three to four months.
But remember, every baby is different! Some newborns only experience a short period of evening fussiness, while others might have several hours of unsettled behaviour each night.
And just because your baby reaches eight weeks doesn't mean everything will suddenly improve overnight. For most families, it's a gradual change as their baby grows and develops.
If your baby's crying is becoming more intense, they're difficult to console for extended periods or you're noticing other concerning symptoms, please don't assume it's just the witching hour.
Our Newborn Sleep Red Flags blog explains when unsettled behaviour may warrant further investigation and when to seek additional support.
While you might not be able to completely prevent the witching hour, there are a few things you can try to make those late afternoons and evenings a little more manageable.
And remember, what works one evening might not work the next. Welcome to newborn life!
Reduce Stimulation in the Late Afternoon
If you've had a busy day with lots of visitors, outings or activity, your newborn might benefit from a quieter environment as the afternoon goes on.
Try dimming the lights, reducing background noise and spending some time in a calm environment.
You don't need to tiptoe around your baby or keep the house completely silent, but reducing stimulation can sometimes help when they're already finding it difficult to settle.
Pay Attention to Awake Time and Daytime Sleep
This is a big one!
If your newborn has spent most of the day having short naps and staying awake for longer than they can comfortably manage, you might find those late afternoons become particularly challenging.
But equally, don't assume that every crying baby needs another nap!
Consider how much sleep your baby has had throughout the day, how long they've been awake and whether they've had enough opportunity to build sleep pressure.
Sometimes a small adjustment to the timing of that final nap or bedtime can make a difference.
Establish a Simple Evening Routine
You absolutely do not need a strict bedtime schedule for your newborn, particularly during those first few weeks.
But having a few familiar steps before sleep can be helpful.
This might be a feed, nappy change, sleeping bag, dimmed lights and some quiet time together before settling.
And PLEASE don't feel like you need to give your baby a bath every single evening for it to count as a bedtime routine!
If you'd like some ideas, have a read of our Creating a Newborn Night Routine blog.
Offer Extra Comfort and Support
Some evenings, your newborn is simply going to need more help settling.
That might mean feeding, rocking, walking around the house, holding them close or trying a different settling technique.
You're not creating bad habits by comforting your newborn!
If they're particularly unsettled, you might also find that babywearing, skin-to-skin contact or a change of scenery helps.
Contact Naps Are Okay Too!
If your newborn is having one of those evenings where they wake the SECOND you put them down, sometimes a contact nap is the most practical option.
You don't need to spend the entire evening attempting cot transfers if they're clearly not working.
Just make sure you're fully awake and alert while holding your baby. If you're feeling drowsy, place them on their back in their own safe sleep space rather than risking falling asleep together on a couch or armchair.
And remember, having contact naps during the newborn stage doesn't mean your baby won't be able to fall asleep independently later on.
Not necessarily!
The witching hour is incredibly common during the newborn stage, and experiencing unsettled evenings doesn't automatically mean there's something wrong with your baby's sleep.
But I also wouldn't dismiss every difficult evening as just another developmental phase that parents have to push through.
Sometimes there are other factors contributing to the fussiness, including how much sleep your baby is getting throughout the day, how long they're spending awake, feeding difficulties or discomfort.
And sometimes? You've considered all of those things, and your newborn still has a particularly unsettled period every evening!
The important thing is understanding what's normal for your baby's age while also recognising when something might need adjusting or further investigation.
If you're unsure what newborn sleep should actually look like, our What to Expect With Newborn Sleep blog walks you through sleep patterns, frequent waking and what you can realistically expect during those early months.
While the witching hour is common during those early newborn weeks, I don't want parents assuming that ALL crying and unsettled behaviour is simply a normal developmental phase.
There are times when we need to investigate what else might be going on.
Some things to look out for include:
Crying that happens throughout the day, rather than predominantly in the late afternoon or evening.
Your baby being consistently difficult to console, even with feeding, holding or other forms of comfort.
Poor weight gain, feeding difficulties or refusing feeds.
Frequent or forceful vomiting, particularly if your baby appears uncomfortable or distressed.
Arching their back, crying or showing signs of discomfort during or after feeds.
A noticeable change in your baby's usual behaviour or crying patterns.
These symptoms don't automatically mean your baby has reflux, but they are worth discussing with your GP, maternal and child health nurse or paediatrician to rule out feeding difficulties or other medical concerns.
And PLEASE don't assume you just need to wait until your baby reaches three or four months for things to improve.
If something doesn't seem right, it's always worth getting it checked rather than putting everything down to the witching hour.
If you are not sure whether your baby's routine is right for this stage, or sleep is starting to feel really hard, our team is here to help.
Based in Melbourne, Australia and supporting families Australia-wide, our team offers:
30-minute sleep consultation - a focused session where we look at your baby's routine, naps, feeds, awake windows, and overnight waking, then give you clear, practical next steps tailored to your family.
Two Week Sleep Support - a fully guided two-week program that includes a personalised sleep plan, a 60-minute consultation, and 10 days of weekday support while you make changes. Ideal if sleep feels really unsustainable and you want more hands-on help.
In-home sleep support - hands-on, face-to-face support for families in Melbourne, Sydney, Byron Bay Shire, Gold Coast and surrounding areas who want someone there with them through the process.
The Sleepy Little Bubs is based in Melbourne and offers virtual sleep consultations across Australia and worldwide.
Whether you need quick clarity or more structured support, we can help you find the right next step.