Which swaddle is best for my baby?

Baby sleeping in a blue arms-up swaddle sleeping bag in a cot

Swaddling can make a huge difference to newborn sleep, particularly in those early weeks when their startle reflex is still quite strong. But here's the thing: not every baby likes being swaddled in the same way!

Some babies love having their arms tucked in close, while others prefer having their hands up near their face. And just because you've tried one swaddle and your baby wasn't happy doesn't mean swaddling isn't going to work for them.

Sometimes it's simply a matter of finding a swaddle that suits your baby's natural sleeping position and allows them to feel comfortable and secure.

Why hand position matters when swaddling

Have you noticed how your newborn naturally positions their hands when they're lying down?

Some babies love having their arms tucked in close to their body, while others constantly bring their hands up towards their face. You might even notice your baby prefers stretching their arms out to the sides.

This is worth paying attention to when choosing a swaddle. A baby who naturally keeps their hands near their face may be more comfortable in an arms-up swaddle, while another baby might settle better with their arms tucked in.

It's not about finding the most expensive or popular swaddle. It's about finding one that your baby is comfortable in, while making sure it fits correctly and allows their hips and legs to move freely.

Babies with hands close to the body and a strong startle reflex

Some newborns naturally keep their hands tucked in close to their chest or by their sides. If your baby also has a strong startle reflex and frequently wakes themselves up with sudden arm movements, a traditional arms-in swaddle might be a good option.

Traditional muslin wraps or properly fitted zip-up and Velcro swaddles can help limit those sudden arm movements, particularly during the early weeks when the startle reflex is quite strong.

One option I love is the Safe Sacs Muslin Wrap, which is a great option for parents who prefer traditional swaddling. You can also get 15% off with code SLB15.

You might find swaddling especially helpful if your newborn is experiencing day-night confusion, when their sleep patterns are still developing and they're waking frequently around the clock.

Just remember, a swaddle should fit securely without being overly tight, particularly around the chest and hips, and you'll need to stop swaddling as soon as your baby shows signs of attempting to roll.

baby swaddled

Babies who prefer sleeping with their hands up

Have you noticed your newborn constantly bringing their hands up towards their face, even when you've tried wrapping them with their arms down?

Some babies naturally prefer sleeping with their hands up near their face or head, and you might find they become frustrated when their arms are tucked down by their sides.

If this sounds like your baby, an arms-up swaddle might be a better option.

These swaddles allow your baby to keep their arms in a more natural position while still helping to reduce those sudden movements caused by the startle reflex.

For some newborns, simply changing from an arms-down to an arms-up swaddle can make a difference to how comfortably they settle and stay asleep.

Remember, arms-up swaddles that restrict arm movement are still swaddles, so they need to be discontinued as soon as your baby shows signs of attempting to roll.

Baby sleeping in a white arms-up swaddle sleeping bag in a cot

Babies who extend their arms outward

Some newborns just aren't fans of having their arms tucked in, and that's okay!

You might notice your baby constantly trying to wriggle their arms free, stretching them out to the sides or becoming frustrated whenever you try to swaddle them.

If this sounds familiar, there's no need to keep persisting with an arms-in swaddle. Some babies are much happier sleeping with their arms completely free from the beginning.

A properly fitted, arms-out sleeping bag, like those from Safe Sacs, can be a great alternative. Your baby can move their arms freely while still staying comfortably dressed for sleep without needing loose blankets.

And remember, not every baby needs to be swaddled! Some are perfectly happy sleeping with their arms out from day one, while others prefer being swaddled for those early weeks.

Regardless of your baby's preference, once they show signs of attempting to roll, it's time to stop swaddling and move to an arms-free sleeping bag.

Baby sleeping in a blue arms-up swaddle sleeping bag in a cot

Fit matters more than brand

You can spend a fortune trying different swaddles, but sometimes it's not the swaddle itself that's the problem. It's how it fits your baby!

A swaddle should fit securely around your baby's upper body without being too tight across their chest, while allowing plenty of room for their hips and legs to move freely.

You also want to make sure there's no loose fabric that could ride up over your baby's face, particularly around their neck and shoulders.

If your newborn is constantly wriggling out of their swaddle, waking with their arms free or ending up with loose fabric around their face, it's worth checking the fit before rushing out to buy another one.

And PLEASE don't try to make a swaddle more secure by wrapping it tighter. Your baby still needs to be able to breathe comfortably and move their hips and legs freely.

Sometimes a different size or style is all that's needed, but if your baby is happier with their arms out, there's absolutely nothing wrong with skipping the swaddle altogether.

Swaddling is not one-size-fits-all

Here's the thing: not every newborn needs to be swaddled, and not every baby is going to love the same type of swaddle!

Some babies settle beautifully with their arms tucked in, others prefer having their hands up near their face, and some are perfectly happy sleeping with their arms completely free.

If your baby is settling comfortably, isn't constantly waking themselves with their startle reflex and seems happy in their swaddle, there's probably no reason to change what you're doing.

But if they're constantly fighting to get their arms out, becoming frustrated or seem more unsettled when swaddled, it might be worth trying a different style.

And if you've tried a few options and your baby still isn't a fan? That's okay too! Swaddling isn't essential for good newborn sleep.

Ultimately, the best swaddle is one that fits safely, suits your baby's preferences and helps them feel comfortable during sleep. And regardless of how well it's working, swaddling must stop as soon as your baby shows signs of attempting to roll.

Common swaddle problems and what to try

If you've tried swaddling your newborn and things aren't quite working, it doesn't necessarily mean you need to give up on swaddling altogether. Sometimes a small adjustment can make a difference!

Your baby keeps breaking out of their swaddle

If you're constantly finding your newborn with one or both arms out, it might be worth trying a properly fitted zip-up or Velcro swaddle that stays securely in place. Just make sure it isn't too tight and there's no loose fabric around their face.

Your baby fights having their arms tucked down

Some babies simply prefer having their hands up near their face! If your newborn is constantly trying to pull their arms up, an arms-up swaddle might be a better option. And if they prefer having their arms completely free, an arms-out sleeping bag is perfectly fine too.

Your baby wakes as soon as you transfer them into the cot

Ahhh, the dreaded cot transfer! Before blaming the swaddle, consider what else might be happening. Your baby may be waking because of the change in position, the loss of physical contact or simply because they're not quite ready to be put down.

It's also worth checking that they're dressed appropriately for the room temperature and aren't becoming too warm.

Your baby settles beautifully but still wakes frequently overnight

This is where I want parents to remember that a swaddle isn't going to magically eliminate night waking.

Newborns wake frequently for lots of reasons, including hunger, their developing sleep patterns and their need for comfort. Even if you've found the perfect swaddle, it's completely normal for your baby to continue waking overnight.

Swaddling can help reduce waking caused by the startle reflex, but it won't remove your newborn's need for feeding or support throughout the night.

Swaddling safety reminders

Swaddling can be a great option during those early newborn weeks, but there are a few important safety guidelines to keep in mind.

Always place your baby on their back for every sleep, both during the day and overnight.

Make sure their swaddle fits securely without being too tight around their chest, and that there is no loose fabric that could come up over their face. Their hips and legs should also have plenty of room to move freely.

Be mindful of overheating, too. Choose a swaddle and clothing appropriate for the room temperature, and avoid covering your baby's head.

And one of the most important things to remember? You need to stop swaddling as soon as your baby shows signs of attempting to roll. You don't need to wait until they've successfully rolled over!

At this stage, it's time to transition to an arms-out sleeping bag that allows both arms to move freely.

If you're unsure when to make the change or how to manage sleep without the swaddle, have a read of our When to Stop Swaddling guide.

How this fits into newborn sleep as a whole

While finding the right swaddle can make a difference, it's important to remember that swaddling is only one small part of newborn sleep.

Your newborn's sleep is still developing, and frequent waking, short naps and needing plenty of support to fall asleep are all completely normal during those early weeks.

Even with the perfect swaddle, your baby is still going to wake for feeds, need comfort and have days where sleep feels a little all over the place!

Understanding what's normal for your baby's age, how much sleep they need and the different ways you can support them to settle can make those early weeks feel a lot less overwhelming.

If you're wondering what newborn sleep should actually look like, have a read of our What to Expect With Newborn Sleep blog.

And if you're looking for practical ways to help your newborn settle, our Settling a Newborn blog walks you through different techniques you can try.

Need personalised support?

Wondering whether your newborn's sleep is normal, if they're getting enough rest, or whether there's something you should be doing differently?

Our Newborn Reassurance Call gives you the opportunity to speak with a certified baby sleep consultant about your baby's sleep, feeding patterns, settling, awake windows and daily rhythms.

We'll discuss what's developmentally appropriate for your baby's age, answer your questions and provide practical, personalised guidance to help you navigate these early weeks with greater confidence.

No strict schedules, no pressure to make changes. Just reassurance, clarity and support when you need it most.

Certified paediatric sleep consultant Eva Beke with her children.

Eva Beke

Certified Paediatric Sleep Consultant

Founder The Sleepy Little Bubs

I’m Eva Beke, a certified baby sleep consultant and founder of The Sleepy Little Bubs, supporting families across Australia and the world with evidence based baby and toddler sleep support.

My approach is realistic, supportive, and designed to evolve as your child grows, so you’re not just getting help for today, but confidence moving forward.

CLIENT STORIES

Real Families. Real Rest.

Baby sleeping after personalised baby sleep consultant support

"Eva is fantastic and helped my family get better sleep."

"I loved the practical advice and lack of judgement - being a mum of a baby who doesn’t sleep is hard and Eva really just gets it and supports you."

- Ashleigh T.

Newborn baby sleeping peacefully after infant sleep support

"Eva helped our little one sleep independently and we will forever be grateful for it!"

"After tweaking his environment and wake windows, with sleep training, we already saw improvements within 3 days. Thank you 🙏🏼"

- Farah F.

Baby sleeping peacefully after sleep consultation support

"Eva showed such kindness and professionalism in our support call."

"I’m so grateful that she made the effort to squeeze me in on short notice, to help a mama in dire need. She’s a gem!

- Johanna S.